2 BUGS: Classical Crossover should NOT be a Classical Subgenre / Non-Classical Tracks on primarily Classical albums should not appear as Works

This has improved massively in the last update and a lot of my music that wasn’t appearing before now does, which is great.

However, I now have several really stubborn albums that I keep tweaking to try and make them go away and it just isn’t working.

I’ve tried removing the “Work” and “Movement” tags, changing the genre to remove “Classical”.

I’ve tried to work this out by comparing certain tracks that DO appear on the offending albums with ones that DON’T but I’m getting a bit at a loss now.

In my last attempt I tried blanking the “soloist” and “soloist_sort” tags. I’ve got 1 track deliberately left with a “Work” and “Movement” to try and get just that single track to appear but no dice.

The weird thing is, genre wise, I have 4 albums by the same artist (Lindsey Stirling) and 1 doesn’t appear at all - it’s got Classical in it’s genre set.

What are the rules? What makes something appear in Classical / Works views or not?

I managed to sort the missing Mike Oldfield tracks, that were missing “Movement” tracks, yet removing them from the Lindsey Stirling albums doesn’t make them go away.

She’s a really tricky artist because she’s proper Classical Crossover - Part classical, Part Pop and a credits list to totally mess up your library; I want to exclude most of her stuff from my Classical view, but some tracks should probably appear. I should be able to manage this with tags but I can’t figure out how!

I’ve dug more into this and have found solid ways to exclude tracks from an Album that seem to work from being Classical:

  • If a part of the album has Works and the items with Works are labelled with a Classical Genre/Subgenre then those items will appear but others won’t (Young Pope Soundtrack)
  • If an album has a Work and none of the tracks have movements and are labelled with a Classical Genre/Subgenre then ALL the tracks appear IN THAT WORK
  • If an album has a Work and SOME of the tracks have movements and are labelled with a Classical Genre/Subgenre then ONLY the tracks appear with a MOVEMENT TAG

This makes a lot of sense and is quite a powerful setup.

To exclude a whole album the only reliable way I found was to delete any Composer Tags from the files (which is a bit overkill but works) - That I’m doing this suggests a Genre issue (see below)

There is a gotcha (THIS IS A BUG (UPDATED) - See below):

  • If you have an album which contains tracks that are PRIMARILY labelled with a Classical Genre/Subgenre AND you have a track or two which are NOT labelled with a Classical Genre/Subgenre they will also (sometimes) appear WHETHER THEY HAVE WORK / MOVEMENT TAGS OR NOT when they match Composers

Then There’s Lindsey Stirling (sigh) / CLASSICAL CROSSOVER
This seems to be the key issue - @lorin.bute I think this is a Genre Taxonomy issue driving my pain. Classical Crossover is a weird genre, and is often misused, but Lindsey Stirling is a prime example of what it should represent. She’s a classically trained violinist and dancer who writes and performs Dubstep / Pop infused with Classical Violin. 9/10 at least of her music doesn’t belong in Classical. It’s a genre that probably belongs under POP and (perhaps) EXPERIMENTAL rather than Classical.

The gotcha isn’t quite - It does appear to be a bug - I originally added this, but have updated it

  • If you have an album which contains tracks that are PRIMARILY labelled with a Classical Genre/Subgenre AND you have a track or two which are NOT labelled with a Classical Genre/Subgenre BUT also have Work / Movement tags they will also appear. This sort of makes sense, and the workaround is to remove the Work tag (TO BE CONFIRMED) (Craig Armstrong - Film Works)

THE ABOVE IS FALSE
Removing any Work and / or Movement tags does NOT help. This was found with “This Love”, a Trip Hop track done with Elizabeth Fraser on 2 of Craig Armstrong’s otherwise primarily classical albums - It has no Work or Movement tags and the Genres for the TRACK are - “Soundtrack; Downtempo; Chamber Pop; Pop; Trip Hop” - This should NOT appear as a work but does.

I have albums that fit this criteria where this does NOT happen, but in all those cases the Composer / Artist is probably different as well, which is not the case here.

WORKAROUND: I removed the extra Composers from the track this introduced to keep the Composers view clean, but if I really needed it to go away completely I think I’d have to clear the Composer tags - ouch!

This has been fixed in the next version.

Thank you for reporting it.